The Pros and Cons of a Raw Food Diet for Dogs

2021-06-04
The Pros and Cons of a Raw Food Diet for Dogs

Raw food diets have become increasingly popular as alternatives to traditional dog food diets. Alongside many other dog food trends like grain-free, vegan or vegetarian, and the use of novel proteins, raw food diets have their pros and cons. Concern among veterinary professionals specifically lies in the safety of this type of diet while some pet owners and enthusiasts argue a raw diet is a healthier option for dogs.

What Is a Raw Food Diet for Dogs?

A raw food diet is one that does not contain cooked items. Unlike traditional, processed dog food, raw dog food does not come in a kibble or canned form. Freeze-dried and frozen options do exist for dog owners that appreciate convenience but still want to offer raw food. Fresh meat, often still on the bone, along with vegetables, grains, organ meats, eggs, fruit, and even some dairy may be part of a homemade, raw diet. Various recipes can be found online but some dog owners don't follow a recipe.

Why Do People Feed Raw Food Diets to Dogs?

Commercial dog food is nutritionally balanced, convenient, and affordable, yet despite these good qualities, some dog owners prefer raw food diets. A desire to feed more "natural" items, concerns with their dog's health, and trust issues with pet food manufacturers may lead a dog owner to go the raw route. Some owners even feel that since a dog's ancestors ate raw foods in the wild, their domesticated dog should, too.

Some dogs have food sensitivities or allergies that make it difficult to purchase commercially prepared diets. These dogs may benefit from a home-prepared meal and some owners opt to feed raw diets. A veterinary nutritionist should be involved in formulating a complete and balanced diet for a dog, even if a raw food diet is utilized, to ensure key nutrients will not be lacking.

What Nutritional Requirements Does a Dog Have?

Dogs can have different nutritional requirements if they have a specific disease but healthy puppies, adults, and pregnant or nursing dogs all require different things from their food, too. This is why different commercial diets exist for dogs in different life stages and also with different health problems. A six-month-old puppy does not have the same nutritional needs as a dog with kidney disease.

Nutrition affects internal organs, skin and coat, bones, muscles, and other parts of your dog, so it is more complicated than some pet owners may realize. Dogs need various vitamins, minerals, proteins, carbohydrates, fibers, and other ingredients to function normally and be healthy. If an improper diet is fed, dogs can develop serious, life-threatening issues, break bones, and not grow properly.

Dogs are omnivores so their nutritional needs reflect that. The Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) helps define and regulate what pets need and pet food manufacturers use these guidelines to make their foods. Domestic dogs are genetically different than their wolf ancestors so even though they are both canines, domestic dogs evolved to be able to digest starches.

Pros and Cons of Raw Food Diets for Dogs

Pros
  • More natural ingredients

  • Ability to choose exactly what your dog eats


    Ability to choose the source of your dog food ingredients

Cons
  • Potential for bacterial and parasitic contamination

  • Potential for nutritional imbalance

  • Potential for tooth injuries from bones

  • Expensive

  • Time consuming to prepare

The biggest concern people have with feeding raw food diets is the potential for bacterial and parasitic contamination and infection, even in previously frozen meats. Raw meats can harbor bacteria like Salmonella, Listeria, and E. coli as well as microscopic parasites like Sarcocystis and Toxoplasma. These pathogens can cause serious infections in both people and pets. Additionally, raw food diets are more expensive than commercially prepared kibble or canned food, can cause tooth injuries if they include bones, and are more time-consuming to prepare.

On the other hand, raw food dog diets allow a pet owner to choose exactly what their dog is eating. They can avoid specific ingredients, know what the sources of the ingredients, and can ensure their dog is getting a more natural diet like a wolf would eat.

Regardless of what type of diet you choose to feed your dog, make sure it is nutritionally complete and balanced. Dogs need more than just raw meat, so a veterinary nutritionist should be involved in formulating your dog's diet to ensure no nutrients are lacking.

Related Article

10 Obscure, Little-known Canine Facts in Honor of National Dog Day

10 Obscure, Little-known Canine Facts in Honor of National Dog Day

With National Dog Day upon us, it's time to celebrate everything about our favorite pets—even the weirder stuff. Here are 10 obscure facts about dogs you probably didn't know.
Exploring the Different Types of Pet-Friendly Beaches

Exploring the Different Types of Pet-Friendly Beaches

Are you looking for pet-friendly beaches? Learn about the different types of pet-friendly beaches, their locations, and tips for visiting them with your pet.
Toxic Chemicals & Household Items That Can Poison Dogs

Toxic Chemicals & Household Items That Can Poison Dogs

There are many things in and around your home that can endanger your dog. Learn which chemicals and household items can poisin your dog.
Bronchitis in Dogs

Bronchitis in Dogs

Is your dog coughing and feeling unwell? It could be due to respiratory inflammation called bronchitis. Learn the causes, treatment, and prevention.
Choking in Dogs

Choking in Dogs

A dog can occasionally swallow something incorrectly and start choking. Find out how you can tell if your dog is choking and what you can do about it.
Why Does My Dog Smell So Bad?

Why Does My Dog Smell So Bad?

Does your dog smell? Find out what could be causing these unpleasant odors and if it's something that needs more than just a bath to fix.
Is Rosemary Safe for Dogs?

Is Rosemary Safe for Dogs?

Rosemary is used both for cooking and as a supplement with many reported health benefits in people, so you may be wondering if it is safe to give to your dog. Rosemary is considered non-toxic for dogs but with some caveats.
Can Dogs Eat Blueberries?

Can Dogs Eat Blueberries?

Dogs can safely eat blueberries. Blueberries are packed with nutrients and can be a great addition to your dog's diet when fed in moderation. Learn more about the benefits, risks, how to incorporate blueberries into their diet, and other fruits dogs can eat.
Dog Food Basics

Dog Food Basics

Are you feeding your dog the best way possible? Check out these dog feeding tips to keep your dog healthy and happy.
Swedish Vallhund: Dog Breed Characteristics & Care

Swedish Vallhund: Dog Breed Characteristics & Care

​The Swedish vallhund makes for a high-energy and affectionate companion. Learn about the breed's history, health, exercise needs, and more.
Becoming a Show Dog: Getting Started

Becoming a Show Dog: Getting Started

Do you have the perfect puppy? Have you considered showing her in a dog show? There's much more to showing than showing up! Here's how to get started.
How to Care for a Hairless Cat

How to Care for a Hairless Cat

Hairless cats make great pets but they aren't without their own challenges and requirements. Read on to learn how to best care for your furless feline.
British Shorthair: Breed Profile, Characteristics & Care

British Shorthair: Breed Profile, Characteristics & Care

The British Shorthair is a calm, affectionate cat that looks and feels like a plush teddy bear. Here's what you need to know about this popular breed, including appearance, temperament, health, and care.
Tonkinese: Cat Breed Profile, Characteristics & Care

Tonkinese: Cat Breed Profile, Characteristics & Care

The Tonkinese cat is a perfect mix of the Siamese and Burmese—smart, sociable, and sweet. Learn about the Tonkinese breed.
How to Stop Your Cat From Chewing Electrical Cords

How to Stop Your Cat From Chewing Electrical Cords

Cats are known to pounce and attack inanimate objects, like electrical cords. Learn how to prevent your cat from ambushing objects that may harm it.
How to Stop Aggression in Kittens

How to Stop Aggression in Kittens

Kittens may show aggressive behavior for several reasons. Sometimes their play gets too aggressive while other times the kitten is afraid or upset. Learn how to spot and curb aggression in kittens.
46 Egyptian Cat Names

46 Egyptian Cat Names

Whether inspired by notable Egyptian deities, locales, or pharaohs, Egyptian cat names can bring out the divinity of your noble feline companion.
How to Tell If a Kitten is a Boy or a Girl

How to Tell If a Kitten is a Boy or a Girl

If you're wondering whether your new kitten is a boy or a girl, here are three ways to help determine the sex of your cat.
Signs Your Cat Is Aging and When to See the Vet

Signs Your Cat Is Aging and When to See the Vet

Expect some changes when your cat ages. Learn to differentiate between normal and potential medical problems for your elderly cat.
Coronavirus in Cats

Coronavirus in Cats

Feline coronavirus (FCoV) rarely harms cats but can lead to another life-threatening illness. Learn the causes, treatment, and prevention.